Skip to main content

Supreme Court Ruling Highlights Importance of Fiduciary Responsibility

The recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling in Tibble vs. Edison has been described as “historic,” “ground-breaking,” and even “revolutionary.” The significant attention this case has generated is due in large part to the fact that a case about retirement plans reached the Supreme Court and that the Supreme Court unanimously overturned the lower courts’ decisions.

Yet, the underlying premise behind the decision in this case is not particularly glamorous. It is very familiar to us all: the fiduciary responsibilities of a plan sponsor.


The key points of the case are as follows:
  • Mr. Tibble argued that his employer, Edison International, acted imprudently by including higher-cost retail mutual funds in the retirement plan when lower-cost institutional-class funds were available.
  • Both the District Court and the Ninth Circuit Court ruled that the six-year statute of limitations precluded the claims from being brought.
  • The Supreme Court overturned the lower courts’ rulings and declared that “a fiduciary is required to conduct a regular review of its investment with the nature and timing of the review contingent on the circumstances.” 

In the summary statements, the Supreme Court stated that “the duty of prudence involves a continuing duty to monitor investments and remove imprudent ones under trust law . . . .” In this statement, plan sponsors are reminded that as a fiduciary, they are ultimately responsible for their plan.

A plan fiduciary’s responsibilities include 1) acting solely in the interest of plan participants and beneficiaries, 2) offering a diversified set of investments, 3) abiding by the law and the plan documents, 4) using plan assets exclusively for the plan, and 5) as clearly demonstrated by this case, acting prudently. However, no specific criteria are given for how to perform these duties.

As your Retirement Plan Adviser, HANYS Benefit Services guides you through these steps, creating an environment where you can properly make these decisions in a way that is required by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). We are your prudent experts. We act as a co-fiduciary to your plan, sharing your obligation and responsibilities to make prudent decisions on your retirement plan.

Read Fiduciary Roles And Responsibilities Under ERISA Defined Contribution Retirement Plans to learn more about being a plan fiduciary. If you have questions, please get in touch by calling (800) 388-1963 or email us at hbs@hanys.org.

Popular posts from this blog

COVID-19: Retirement and Benefit Plan Resources

As the COVID-19 crisis continues to unfold, we are closely monitoring news and updates from top sources. We’ll be updating this section as new developments unfold. Here are several key articles and links to help plan sponsors and administrators navigate the COVID-19 impact to retirement and benefit plans: Retirement Plans 4 Key CARES Act Provisions for Retirement Plan Sponsors Markets React to Coronavirus   Important Considerations for Retirement Plan Sponsors during the Coronavirus Pandemic In Fed We Trust Participant Education Services: Timely Help from a Safe Distance CRDs 100% Taxable for New York State and Local Income Tax Purposes in 2020 IRS Permits Remote Notarization of Participant Elections   Employee Benefits CARES Act Expands Health Coverage Rules Understanding the Historic $2 Trillion Stimulus Package Employee Compensation and Benefits During Closures and Furloughs DOL Clarifies Exemptions to Coronavirus Paid Leave Laws Small Business Exemption to

Coronavirus-related distributions 100% taxable for New York state and local income tax purposes in 2020

The Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security (CARES) Act was signed into law on March 27. Under the Act, participants affected by the coronavirus may be able to take distributions in 2020 of up to $100,000 from an employer-sponsored retirement plan or an IRA. Although allowing these distributions from a qualified retirement plan is optional, we have seen that a number of employers have chosen to amend their plans to permit such distributions. The Act provides that coronavirus-related distributions will not be subject to the mandatory 20% withholding nor the 10% early withdrawal penalty (for those younger than 59½) that would otherwise apply.

Timely Elections of 457(b) Distributions

If you sponsor a non-governmental 457(b) tax-exempt plan for your key management and highly compensated employees, perhaps the most significant administrative task occurs at the time participants sever employment.  Each 457(b) plan has a specified time period by which a participant may make an election to defer payment and timely postpone taxation by electing a future distribution date.  If no timely election is made by the end of the specified time period (“default date”), payment will commence within a generally brief period of time after the default date elapses, which may not be what the participant intended.